I sent the text below to the Irish Times. If its published I will acknowledge it in this blog.
Nobody on the yes side (although nobody on the NO side either) has raised any concerns about the children locked up in st pats prison.
There are many good reasons IMHO for those children to be either released or moved to a safer facility.
The general concensus seems to be that these children are convicted of criminal offences and therefore somehow deserve what they get in prison.
There is no acknowledgement that many if not all of these children ended up in prison because the state failed them in the first place.
To my mind anybody that is concerned about the welfare of children in Ireland should be screaming from the rooftops for their release, and in the absence of them not taking a very rigid public stance on this issue, I have to contemplate why they would expect me to vote in agreement with them.
I am growing very suspicious of this complete concensus,and the way the yes side are demonising anybody who expresses doubt that a change in the constitution will fix what is wrong with the way official Ireland deals with children, makes me more suspicious by the day.
I want to vote YES but my conscience does not sit comfortably with a change in the law that may make things worse for children.
Regards
John Fitzpatrick
Wednesday, October 31, 2012
Monday, October 22, 2012
Questions for the YES side.
Why would we trust the state when the state has abysmally failed children in the past?
Why are children still locked up with their abusers in Saint pats prison.
Why has none of the adults (referred to in the recent report on Saint Pats,) been arrested, charged or sacked?
Why did they wait for months before they made the report on saint pats prison public.
Why are Irish children born to non irish parents being deported?
What safe guards and precautions will be put in place to insure that a married couple will not end up selling their children?
What criminal charges will brought against state employees and and state sub contractors for negligence or not doing their job properly when dealing with children and their parents?
From a fella called Eddie Walsh on the FG facebook page.
Vote yes !!!!!it was the state that fed children through the state courts to the concentration camps run by the church and paid for by the state..It was the state that removed children from their homes and families for absolutely no reason but to fill these concentration camps.It was the judges that signed the orders to lock up these innocent children in these hell holes.Look at the latest rulings by JUDGES on rapists and this Referendum is giving the state the absolute power to retrospectively remove children from their families and force an adoption
Why are children still locked up with their abusers in Saint pats prison.
Why has none of the adults (referred to in the recent report on Saint Pats,) been arrested, charged or sacked?
Why did they wait for months before they made the report on saint pats prison public.
Why are Irish children born to non irish parents being deported?
What safe guards and precautions will be put in place to insure that a married couple will not end up selling their children?
What criminal charges will brought against state employees and and state sub contractors for negligence or not doing their job properly when dealing with children and their parents?
From a fella called Eddie Walsh on the FG facebook page.
Vote yes !!!!!it was the state that fed children through the state courts to the concentration camps run by the church and paid for by the state..It was the state that removed children from their homes and families for absolutely no reason but to fill these concentration camps.It was the judges that signed the orders to lock up these innocent children in these hell holes.Look at the latest rulings by JUDGES on rapists and this Referendum is giving the state the absolute power to retrospectively remove children from their families and force an adoption
Thursday, October 18, 2012
Nolan TD facebook page
Derek Nolan TD · 152 like this.
9 hours ago ·
My Response to Recent Facebook Posts
I would like to respond to the inaccurate and unfair claims made about my attempt to help a constituent requiring treatment for pain.
I first met with my constituent’s husband on Friday October 5th and agreed to do all that I could to help in the situation. I wholeheartedly understand that this is an extremely difficult situation for my constituent and her family.
On Monday the 8th my staff and I made many enquiries to the relevant clinic and have been in ongoing contact with them in relation to this patients need.
On the 9th, my constituent’s husband called my office and was given an update.
On the 10th, a member of my staff again contacted the HSE via email and phone call.
On the 11th, the HSE were again contacted and a member of my staff spoke with a staff member there and tried to get an earlier appointment for this constituent. On the same day, my constituent’s husband was contacted to update him on the conversations between the HSE and my staff.
I fully refute that my office has not been trying to help and further the case of my constituent and that my office has not been in touch since with my constituent. It is simply untrue.
I cannot disclose the full details of the case as it is personal and confidential and I must respect that. However, further to making enquiries with the HSE, I have been attempting to get statistics from the clinic about their out-patients numbers. This is with a view to raising this issue in the Dáil and getting the attention it deserves so that people do not have to suffer from pain while waiting between appointments. I informed my constituent’s husband of this.
I called my constituent’s husband on Monday October 15th to discuss the matter further but there was no answer.
The following Wednesday, following a phone call to my office, I contacted my constituents husband to discuss the matter. The first thing I said was that I was still trying to get progress on the issue and that I was raising the whole topic of delays with the pain clinic with the HSE. In fact, my office has been in contact with the CEO of Galway University Hospital in relation to the issue.
During the phone call I did communicate my dissatisfaction with unfair and inaccurate comments left on Twitter, comments which implied that I was not doing anything to help. I found this very insulting to me, and to my staff, as we have been working very hard to try and secure an appointment for my constituent in the clinic.
I have been a TD now for 19 months and have dealt with over 1,600 individual contacts from constituents. This is the first time that I have felt that my good name has been unfairly treated in this manner. I came to politics to help people and to represent the people of Galway West to the very best of my ability. I treat everyone who comes into my office with the utmost respect, but I expect the same in return.
Finally, as I informed my constituent’s husband yesterday, I will keep working to get an appointment and am in constant contact with the HSE in relation to this issue. I hope that it can be resolved soon.
2Unlike · · Share
You and 50 others like this.
View all 24 comments
Hugh Hamill Thanks for clearing up what actually happened Derek. It's very easy to get the virtual pitchforks and torches out on facebook and twitter these days, absent the full facts. Everyone should bear in mind that the girl who made the initial post is only 1...See More
9 hours ago · Like · 21
Anthony Muldoon Well said Hugh
8 hours ago · Like · 5
Jennifer Banks Derek I am the constituent in question and I would like to put my side: This was NEVER about me Steve went to your office in anger at the cuts at the hse which have resulted in this situation we waned you to let the people know what Dr Reilly and the hse were doing to us and thousands like me.
7 hours ago · Like · 8
Lisa Power Hugh it has nothing to do with the girl in question been 15 every one has a voice no matter what ok!!
7 hours ago via mobile · Like · 1
Josie O'Brien Good on you Jennifer,and a td is not a doctor,and i think its very unproffessionial of him to post on fb....
7 hours ago · Like
Jennifer Banks cond; Steve has been phoning your office daily as our situation at home deteriorated, he wanted to try and help as he was now helpless. To date our contact with your office has resulted in a suggestion we were trying to queue jump? other than your meet...See More
7 hours ago · Like · 7
Jennifer Banks @Hugh I had no idea what Keira was doing until I was alerted by a friend, I am very proud of her and she only restated the facts as we knew them if Derek Nolan is in contact with the HSE it would have been nice if he or a member of his staff told us? I began this with others to highlight the reality of life at the mercy of the health service.
7 hours ago · Like · 2
Hugh Hamill Jennifer, that was my point, that everyone should remember that she didn't have all the facts available to her when she made the post, which was not her fault. Anyway, good luck to you & your family, hopefully this will have a positive outcome in terms of highlighting the issues you face to a wider audience.
7 hours ago · Like
Jennifer Banks Derek Steve has asked me to relay to you how hurt he is that you are accusing him of untruths he asked me to state that the only time he spoke with your office was when he 'phoned them' and other than the mention of queue jumping he was NEVER made awar...See More
6 hours ago · Like · 3
Josie O'Brien Jennifer i think you are a very strong Person and as his reputation he ruined it him self by posting on here,...
6 hours ago · Like
Paula K O Brien It is a terrible truth that our health service is a shambles and that people like you suffer every day when it is your right to get help as and when you need it....its a basic human right. However, i do think that Derek Nolan is a person of integrity and would do all in his power to help his constituents...even if he is up against a brick wall at times.
6 hours ago via mobile · Like · 2
Laurence Darcy You allege you have done thinga to help Jennifer Banks and her suffering.. If you have. You have failed miserably. Jennifer is still suffering in chronic Pain. And taking Highly addictive drug. And her situation is getting worse. Time you stop talking and took some positive and affirmative action until this is solve. Sick of thoses that talk and do nothing.
5 hours ago · Like · 1
Keira Banks @Hugh i may only be 15 , but trust me i knew everything ! i knew every little thing that has gone on , as Jennifer is my mother and unfortunately i witness first hand her pain and i have for 12 years ! there is only so much one person can take from thi...See More
5 hours ago · Like · 16
Debbie Tilley Mr Nolan this is a family in dire need of help, you feel insulted? is this anything like being in constant pain for 12 years and feeling alone? Turning to you for help? get off Facebook and trying to justify yourself and make your actions count, that is why I assume you were elected. Facebook or twitter is not your platform, government and policies are
4 hours ago via mobile · Like · 2
Whitney Woodside This situation is too much for FB anyway. Should be dealt with professionally.
4 hours ago · Like · 1
Ciara Leena G People do realise that you didn't single-handedly crash the country and enforce health cuts, right? And that electing clientalistic politicians is more or less exactly what got us where we are? Also, exactly what did the other politicians from Galway do for this family, and why aren't they receiving equal levels of criticism?
4 hours ago via mobile · Like · 3
Michael O Connor I appreciate that Derek took time to establish the facts and we should always hear two sides of the story.
What's not clear is the conflicting accounts. The daughter says no phone call for two weeks whereas Derek says regular calls and updates.
Eith...See More
3 hours ago via mobile · Like · 1
Ger Kavanagh you must have very thin skin Mr Nolan it comes with the job like it or not and if you're not able for it stand down.I have had to put up with far worse in my workplace on a regular basis and if i complained about it first question I'd be asked is why did you join so,so Mr Nolan TD my advice is to do your job and dont expect pats on the back when doing it,it's your job and the Irish people are paying you well for it
2 hours ago via mobile · Like · 2
Martin Kingston I have never met Mr Nolan or am i a constituent of his, however, given what we read and hear, dealing with the HSE must be one of the great horrors of public life. I hope this woman is on adequate pain relief as soon as is possible but speaking as a former member of a local authority, dealing with government bodies, even as an elected public representative, can be utterly soul destroying.
about an hour ago · Like
Jennifer Banks I want this Nolan slapping to stop we raised this issue because of the cuts in the hse Derek Nolan spoke to steve once on the phone and NEVER relayed any of the work he has or has not doing on our behalf, his call was about my online comments and in th...See More
about an hour ago · Like · 1
Georgina Russell Mr. Nolan,
I do hope you have taken the actions that you have described in the above response, as it is your job to take action when asked by one of your constituents in dire need for help. However I think it much more likely that you are facing the ou...See More
53 minutes ago · Like · 3
John Fitzpatrick Derek
I am very disappointed that you chose to comment in this issue in such a public manner. I would like to point out that as a very well paid public servant you should have a respect for citizens dignity.
Your attempt to rebuff a young person for not accepting that you are doing enough to help her extremely ill mother is most condescending to say the least. It definitely lacks any humility on your behalf, and also smacks of a complete indifference to the plight of many people in Ireland that can not access the public health services.
You constanly refer to your “constituent” as though you are trying to preserve your “constituents” identity, when in fact the dogs on the street know that you are referring to Jennifer Banks, so although you did not use her name it is quite clear who you are referring to.
Jennifer Banks has been attempting to highlight the plight of MS sufferers for weeks now, and has resorted to all and any social media she can access, and has been on a number of broadcast media (local and National) in her quest.
While I accept that you may have been trying to get some assistance for her, you, as a TD for the constituency, should, have been aware of her and others plight (both in the constituency you represent, and also the position nationally), that's your job. To know what is going wrong and to use your position as a TD get it fixed.
You may have been better to contact Jennifer Banks directly and asked her to work with you to highlight her difficulties, which would of course hopefully help to resolve the matter for her and everyone else.
You say that you are a TD for only 19 months which implies that you are still learning the job. When you asked for the job, you did not say that you would be on a learning curve, in fact you said the opposite, i.e. You said you would very definitely represent your constituency the way the people wanted you to represent them. You say you are doing your best, well it seems your best is not good enough. And for over one hundred thousand euro per year plus expenses I did not expect to get an apprentice, that would require a long learning time.
Your mantra about you being busy looking after the economy has been challenged on many occasions, with response of “at what cost” the answer being, the lives, welfare, and suffering of people. While saving and rescuing the economy is an admirable aspiration, the cost of that success is being borne by the ordinary people of Ireland, and Roisin Shortalls resignation clearly acknowledges that. I suspect that when it eventually dawns on many TDs, just, how much the public are suffering, we will hear many apologies of I,m sorry, I didn,t know, just like Charlie Haughey did in the 80s. Well by then it will be too late for many ordinary citizens of Ireland, and their families will have to live with the knowledge that their country did not help their loved ones when they needed it most.
Your response to Keira Banks has done nothing but reinforce peoples opinion that all them politicians are only in it for themselves, and, does nothing but disgrace the many many many heroic efforts of ordinary unpaid volunteers in the political arena, as well as belittle those that work tirelessly unpaid in the background to try to improve our country for the good of all.
Keira Banks facebook comment has achieved almost ten thousand likes, and almost 500 comments. They are the kind of figures that only the best known celebrities, with thousands of friends achieve, and is equivalent in Irish social media terms to twenty minutes of prime time television.
Again I am very disappointed in the way you have dealt with this issue, and I suggest that you immediately make the most wholesome apology to the entire Banks family for your actions, in as public a manner that you can think of.
48 minutes ago · Like
Derek Sasha Mr. Nolan, this case is being watched from overseas. People like me are observing what happens when the representatives of people in pain make ineffectual gestures and think that's enough. Mr, Nolan, you are in a job where empty words hurt real people and only real results count. This is a big lesson to us in the US who are thinking about who to vote for in the next Presidential election, just as it is for people in your constituency who are thinking about whether you are able to support a just society in which people in need get treated with compassion and dignity.
17 minutes ago · Like
Monday, June 18, 2012
Match Tickets from 3.ie
This story goes as follows.
I won two tickets to the Ireland vs Italy soccer match from three.ie.
I got a tweet asking me to contact them by email.
I sent them an email, they then asked for my name and address (as it appears on my official ID).
Text from email as follows:
Hi John, Yes, congratulations! We need your name as it appears on your ID to give to UEFA, can you provide this along with your address to have the tickets sent over before next week? Thanks, Patrick
I sent them the details and they already had my home phone number and my mobile phone number, my twitter account name, and now my email address. I got a return email, saying that was fine and they would courier the tickets out to me on Monday 11th of June.
Text from email as follows: Thanks John, we'll have those couriered out to you on Monday. Well done again!
My sons decided that they would send me over to Poznan for the game (as a present for fathers day). I insisted however that booking flights etc, would not be a good idea until I had the tickets in my hands. As it is only two physical paper tickets, I went to work on Monday, hoping they would be in my letterbox when I got home. They were not there. I assume it's just a minor glitch in the three.ie system. Went to work on Tuesday, again expecting the tickets to be in the letterbox when I get home, and also thinking that I should contact three.ie about it, (but then decide that I don't want to be wasting peoples time, so I wait), still thinking though that it is glitch in the system, and hoping it will work itself out without any hassle to anybody, (alls well that ends well), and all that. Wednesday arrives and I go to work this time determined to contact three.ie. I decide to wait until the afternoon lunch break is over. I then get a call to my mobile from three.ie, saying they have been trying to contact me since Monday. However neither my mobile phone, mu home phone, my email, or my twitter account has recorded any attempt by three.ie to contact me. The cynic in me now is thinking,what's really going on here? Anyway three.ie then reels me I have to be in my house to sign for the tickets from the courier. I tell them I can,t be there until later on as I am working. They say I can collect them myself from their head office. They say they will be left in the reception, and they close about 5.15pm, and so I agree to collect them from the reception, and off I go on my merry little way. A few minutes later I get another call from three.ie. they say they need my passport details to give to UEFA. I tell him my passport is. At home, and I,ll call and give the details when I get home. I leave things at that, and go off on my merry little way (don't forget I,m working through all of this stuff). I,m out working and phone is now on silent, and at 7.20pm (which is the first time I get to check my phone) shows I have a missed call and a text message. Pic below:
Pic of The text message.
IMHO the significant words in this text are "I,ll have to pass them on, I,m afraid"
So at this point I decide my cynicism was justified and I decide to send an email to three.ie outlining my disappointment.
The text is as follows:
Hi Patrick I have to say I am very disappointed the way the issue of the tickets that I won has been handled. I was asked by you on Friday for my name address on id etc, and I gave it. Was assured the tickets would be couriered out on Monday. Only got your call today and rang you back as soon as I could park the car, (which was only a couple of minutes after your call). I arranged to collect them from your offices. You then said you needed passport details which I don't carry around with me, I told you I would send the details to you when I got home, where my passport is located. I was on a job driving people around for the next few hours and could not answer my phone and then I get this message telling me (I have until 6 oclock to get my passport details to you) or you will have to pass them on. I don,t think thats right. I won them fair and square, and thus they are my tickets. I complied with everything I was asked to do, and in my opinion they are my tickets (to do with them whatever I want). Anyway the fun has been taken off them, and I just want to register my great disappointment, with the way Three has handled this. Not ringing me until Wednesday was very bad form, (even if it was an oversight) for tickets for a match in Poznan 5 days later is a bit off the wall.
Regards.
The return email is as follows.
HI John, Thanks for your mail. As I explained to you on the phone, I had been trying to get through to you since Monday. My main prerogative is to get rid of the tickets and at this time, I still have them. I did not know that UEFA would request your details and as soon as I did, I contacted you. I still have the tickets as I said so if you want to get your passport details through to me asap, they're yours. Best regards,
My response is as follows:
Patrick my details were emailed to you with my home number and my mobile number. I have no unanswered missed calls on my mobile and no private numbers are showing on my incoming call list on the home phone, and the only contact I had by phone with you (yesterday) had an almost immediate response from me, and my phone can show that. It took you five full days to contact me by mobile phone (which seems incredible) since you are acting on behalf of a mobile phone company. At that point I assumed the tickets were almost 100% in my hands, and then was mentally preparing to book flights, airport transfers,hotels etc, until, that is, I seen your text message (btw which I did not see until after 7pm as the phone was in my pocket). You text message very clearly stated that if you did not get my passport details by six oclock yesterday evening, you would "pass them on". There is no ambiguity in that statement, and clearly nobody would arrange flights etc, based on that statement. In any event, based on that statement, I told my son (who was bringing me over for the game as a fathers day present) not to make any arrangements to fly as the tickets were now gone. Luckily i had asked him not to book the flights until I had the tickets in my hand. Either way, as I have said, the novelty and goodwill has been lost on these tickets and its now far too late to book flights etc. As you say, "my main prerogative is to get rid of the tickets", can I point out again to you, they were won in a fair competition by me, and therefore (in my book) that makes them my tickets, which in turn, means you do not have the right to (as you say) get rid of them. I think you can take it that I personally will not be going to POZNAN see Ireland playing Italy in the 2012 Euro finals, (unless they both end up in the final). By all means you can feel free to "get rid of them", Under these circumstances I won,t be availing of them, and I will let THREE know of my disappointment. I don,t know if you work directly for THREE, but, I will take this up at a senior management level with THREE. With immense disappointment.
Regards John Fitzpatrick
One particular thing I find absolutely irritating in this is that a company that sells mobile communications as its primary product, is somehow trying to blame the telecommunications systems for its own failures in communicating with me, despite the fact that it had 4 different communications systems available to it, (namely, land-line, mobile phone line, email address, and twitter account). Thats MADDENING TED.
I am in two minds as to how I should deal with this now. Have I got a legal leg to stand on? If I have legal rights, what are they?
Have I got a moral leg to stand on? I know this much, if I had won these tickets in a pub raffle I,d be up in arms over not getting them.
Should I seek compensation of some kind? Should I seek a gesture from three.ie? Should I take it up with three.ie, or should I just leave it and ignore it?
What do you think?
Text from email as follows:
Hi John, Yes, congratulations! We need your name as it appears on your ID to give to UEFA, can you provide this along with your address to have the tickets sent over before next week? Thanks, Patrick
I sent them the details and they already had my home phone number and my mobile phone number, my twitter account name, and now my email address. I got a return email, saying that was fine and they would courier the tickets out to me on Monday 11th of June.
Text from email as follows: Thanks John, we'll have those couriered out to you on Monday. Well done again!
My sons decided that they would send me over to Poznan for the game (as a present for fathers day). I insisted however that booking flights etc, would not be a good idea until I had the tickets in my hands. As it is only two physical paper tickets, I went to work on Monday, hoping they would be in my letterbox when I got home. They were not there. I assume it's just a minor glitch in the three.ie system. Went to work on Tuesday, again expecting the tickets to be in the letterbox when I get home, and also thinking that I should contact three.ie about it, (but then decide that I don't want to be wasting peoples time, so I wait), still thinking though that it is glitch in the system, and hoping it will work itself out without any hassle to anybody, (alls well that ends well), and all that. Wednesday arrives and I go to work this time determined to contact three.ie. I decide to wait until the afternoon lunch break is over. I then get a call to my mobile from three.ie, saying they have been trying to contact me since Monday. However neither my mobile phone, mu home phone, my email, or my twitter account has recorded any attempt by three.ie to contact me. The cynic in me now is thinking,what's really going on here? Anyway three.ie then reels me I have to be in my house to sign for the tickets from the courier. I tell them I can,t be there until later on as I am working. They say I can collect them myself from their head office. They say they will be left in the reception, and they close about 5.15pm, and so I agree to collect them from the reception, and off I go on my merry little way. A few minutes later I get another call from three.ie. they say they need my passport details to give to UEFA. I tell him my passport is. At home, and I,ll call and give the details when I get home. I leave things at that, and go off on my merry little way (don't forget I,m working through all of this stuff). I,m out working and phone is now on silent, and at 7.20pm (which is the first time I get to check my phone) shows I have a missed call and a text message. Pic below:
Pic of The text message.
IMHO the significant words in this text are "I,ll have to pass them on, I,m afraid"
So at this point I decide my cynicism was justified and I decide to send an email to three.ie outlining my disappointment.
The text is as follows:
Hi Patrick I have to say I am very disappointed the way the issue of the tickets that I won has been handled. I was asked by you on Friday for my name address on id etc, and I gave it. Was assured the tickets would be couriered out on Monday. Only got your call today and rang you back as soon as I could park the car, (which was only a couple of minutes after your call). I arranged to collect them from your offices. You then said you needed passport details which I don't carry around with me, I told you I would send the details to you when I got home, where my passport is located. I was on a job driving people around for the next few hours and could not answer my phone and then I get this message telling me (I have until 6 oclock to get my passport details to you) or you will have to pass them on. I don,t think thats right. I won them fair and square, and thus they are my tickets. I complied with everything I was asked to do, and in my opinion they are my tickets (to do with them whatever I want). Anyway the fun has been taken off them, and I just want to register my great disappointment, with the way Three has handled this. Not ringing me until Wednesday was very bad form, (even if it was an oversight) for tickets for a match in Poznan 5 days later is a bit off the wall.
Regards.
The return email is as follows.
HI John, Thanks for your mail. As I explained to you on the phone, I had been trying to get through to you since Monday. My main prerogative is to get rid of the tickets and at this time, I still have them. I did not know that UEFA would request your details and as soon as I did, I contacted you. I still have the tickets as I said so if you want to get your passport details through to me asap, they're yours. Best regards,
My response is as follows:
Patrick my details were emailed to you with my home number and my mobile number. I have no unanswered missed calls on my mobile and no private numbers are showing on my incoming call list on the home phone, and the only contact I had by phone with you (yesterday) had an almost immediate response from me, and my phone can show that. It took you five full days to contact me by mobile phone (which seems incredible) since you are acting on behalf of a mobile phone company. At that point I assumed the tickets were almost 100% in my hands, and then was mentally preparing to book flights, airport transfers,hotels etc, until, that is, I seen your text message (btw which I did not see until after 7pm as the phone was in my pocket). You text message very clearly stated that if you did not get my passport details by six oclock yesterday evening, you would "pass them on". There is no ambiguity in that statement, and clearly nobody would arrange flights etc, based on that statement. In any event, based on that statement, I told my son (who was bringing me over for the game as a fathers day present) not to make any arrangements to fly as the tickets were now gone. Luckily i had asked him not to book the flights until I had the tickets in my hand. Either way, as I have said, the novelty and goodwill has been lost on these tickets and its now far too late to book flights etc. As you say, "my main prerogative is to get rid of the tickets", can I point out again to you, they were won in a fair competition by me, and therefore (in my book) that makes them my tickets, which in turn, means you do not have the right to (as you say) get rid of them. I think you can take it that I personally will not be going to POZNAN see Ireland playing Italy in the 2012 Euro finals, (unless they both end up in the final). By all means you can feel free to "get rid of them", Under these circumstances I won,t be availing of them, and I will let THREE know of my disappointment. I don,t know if you work directly for THREE, but, I will take this up at a senior management level with THREE. With immense disappointment.
Regards John Fitzpatrick
One particular thing I find absolutely irritating in this is that a company that sells mobile communications as its primary product, is somehow trying to blame the telecommunications systems for its own failures in communicating with me, despite the fact that it had 4 different communications systems available to it, (namely, land-line, mobile phone line, email address, and twitter account). Thats MADDENING TED.
I am in two minds as to how I should deal with this now. Have I got a legal leg to stand on? If I have legal rights, what are they?
Have I got a moral leg to stand on? I know this much, if I had won these tickets in a pub raffle I,d be up in arms over not getting them.
Should I seek compensation of some kind? Should I seek a gesture from three.ie? Should I take it up with three.ie, or should I just leave it and ignore it?
What do you think?
Friday, June 15, 2012
You will never beat the Irish
It strikes me that many people in the media do not understand the cultural significance of singing Y,I'll never beat de oirish.
The words seem to be what's causing most commentators to get confused. They seem to think the words refer to the result of the game, (and sometimes it does). But, on most occasions of soccer matches, we do not win very often, but we do draw, and thus we are not beaten, hence Y,ill never beat the oirish is a statement of fact on the occasion of a draw.
On the occasions when we are actually beaten, Y,I'll never beat the oirish culturally means that, ye can shuv the result, we don,t care about the match now, and the real competition is about to start. This competition however will have many many many more players than the eleven aside that are permitted on the soccer pitch. I an referring to the spectators game known as the singsong.
It is widely acknowledged by media commentators all over the world, that following a soccer match in which Ireland are one of the teams, you can count on the singsong after the game. And I never heard anyone ever say that the Irish singsong participants were ever beaten.
So hence the words,now, do act as a statement of fact, and it's true, they will never beat the oirish when it comes to the singsong, and culturally no matter how down we might be, we all know there is another metaphorical fight to be fought, and thus our call to metaphorical arms is on, thus we all participate in that particular battle.
We also will never show the world publicly how down we really feel, no matter what they throw at us, sure didn't we put on a brave happy smiley face on things for 800 years, while we fought the English, and they could never understand that particular trait. So fighting a few European countries on the soccer pitch is really a walk in the park, in that context.
So in reality the context of the Y,ill never beat the oirish, is what matters, and sometimes it is a statement of fact, that refers to the after match competition.
So all media commentators should get over their lack of understanding of the Irish Sports fans propensity for singing, You will never beat the Irish. And for the record when the game is on, it bugs the life out of the opposition and sometimes helps to unsettle the opposition. And even if we don,t win the game, we will definitely win the SINGSONG.
My opinion on Roy Keanes comments are that he was clearly aiming his comments at the players and the FAI, and as a proven professional soccer player, he is quite entitled to demand higher standards from other paid professionals. He has always put the supporters first, and I suspect he always will.
The words seem to be what's causing most commentators to get confused. They seem to think the words refer to the result of the game, (and sometimes it does). But, on most occasions of soccer matches, we do not win very often, but we do draw, and thus we are not beaten, hence Y,ill never beat the oirish is a statement of fact on the occasion of a draw.
On the occasions when we are actually beaten, Y,I'll never beat the oirish culturally means that, ye can shuv the result, we don,t care about the match now, and the real competition is about to start. This competition however will have many many many more players than the eleven aside that are permitted on the soccer pitch. I an referring to the spectators game known as the singsong.
It is widely acknowledged by media commentators all over the world, that following a soccer match in which Ireland are one of the teams, you can count on the singsong after the game. And I never heard anyone ever say that the Irish singsong participants were ever beaten.
So hence the words,now, do act as a statement of fact, and it's true, they will never beat the oirish when it comes to the singsong, and culturally no matter how down we might be, we all know there is another metaphorical fight to be fought, and thus our call to metaphorical arms is on, thus we all participate in that particular battle.
We also will never show the world publicly how down we really feel, no matter what they throw at us, sure didn't we put on a brave happy smiley face on things for 800 years, while we fought the English, and they could never understand that particular trait. So fighting a few European countries on the soccer pitch is really a walk in the park, in that context.
So in reality the context of the Y,ill never beat the oirish, is what matters, and sometimes it is a statement of fact, that refers to the after match competition.
So all media commentators should get over their lack of understanding of the Irish Sports fans propensity for singing, You will never beat the Irish. And for the record when the game is on, it bugs the life out of the opposition and sometimes helps to unsettle the opposition. And even if we don,t win the game, we will definitely win the SINGSONG.
My opinion on Roy Keanes comments are that he was clearly aiming his comments at the players and the FAI, and as a proven professional soccer player, he is quite entitled to demand higher standards from other paid professionals. He has always put the supporters first, and I suspect he always will.
Friday, March 30, 2012
The promissory note
My reading of the deal on the promissory note is as follows.We will not pay the money over tomorrow 31st March 2012. We are postponing the payment until 2013 and the cost for that is 90 million euro. But we still have control over the money. We can,t spend it or anything like that, because in order to pay it, we were going to have to borrow it off (ECB, TRoika, IMF) don,t know who, but the fact is its not borrowed and its not paid over.So what no big deal you might say. On the up side of it though, as we have not actually paid it over, in theory we still have control over the decisions on how to use it.Then if things change for us (hopefully for the better) we may be in a different position when March 2013 comes around, and, so we may be able to renegotiate the payment again, and hopefully it will be better for us all in the long term.Thats my simple version of it, I,ve no secret information from any source. Its just my experience of juggling small businesses with cash-flow problems that lead me to believe that its the best deal available at this point in time.Have a nice day.
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Real Irish unemployment rate
There is something wrong with the way the unemployment figures are being calculated. For instance Bertie Aherns biography (and almost all official figures) says he got the unemployment rate from 18.1 percent to less than 3.1 percent. It is widely reported the current rate of unemployment is at 14 percent. These statements bring up a number of issues for me.
The highest I remember unemployment to be was about 220 thousand people. If that is presented officially as 18 percent, then how can today's current figures of 450 thousand be presented as 14 percent.
The figures imply a huge increase in the population, but that figure would need to almost double the population to get 450 thousand people unemployed to represent 14 percent of the population.
We know the population did not double, and we also know there has been a huge number of people emigrating in the past few years, so somehow these figures do not add up.
There is something wrong.
I,m not debating the differences between long term unemployment, short term unemployment, people working short time, permanent part time workers etc etc, it's the actual factual percentage of unemployed people that I am interested in.
While I,m at it I may as well throw out another few issues that bugs me in relation to unemployment.
The CSO figures are calculated on a workforce of people aged between 15 years and 66 years. They do not distinguish between those that are actually still in school, or those that have taken early retirement (which in reality will never work again, and I,m not talking about civil or public servants that take the governments generous offer of an early pension and lump sum payments to retire, and who in reality will be brought back either as employees of quangos, or what is normal, that they are employed as self employed consultants).
I,m talking about people that have been laid off or made redundant and who in reality will never get jobs again, in any area of work. If those people are excluded from the workforce then the real unemployment rate will increase dramatically from the official 14 percent to more than thirty percent (using my anecdotal figures).
So there you go, explain that one.
The highest I remember unemployment to be was about 220 thousand people. If that is presented officially as 18 percent, then how can today's current figures of 450 thousand be presented as 14 percent.
The figures imply a huge increase in the population, but that figure would need to almost double the population to get 450 thousand people unemployed to represent 14 percent of the population.
We know the population did not double, and we also know there has been a huge number of people emigrating in the past few years, so somehow these figures do not add up.
There is something wrong.
I,m not debating the differences between long term unemployment, short term unemployment, people working short time, permanent part time workers etc etc, it's the actual factual percentage of unemployed people that I am interested in.
While I,m at it I may as well throw out another few issues that bugs me in relation to unemployment.
The CSO figures are calculated on a workforce of people aged between 15 years and 66 years. They do not distinguish between those that are actually still in school, or those that have taken early retirement (which in reality will never work again, and I,m not talking about civil or public servants that take the governments generous offer of an early pension and lump sum payments to retire, and who in reality will be brought back either as employees of quangos, or what is normal, that they are employed as self employed consultants).
I,m talking about people that have been laid off or made redundant and who in reality will never get jobs again, in any area of work. If those people are excluded from the workforce then the real unemployment rate will increase dramatically from the official 14 percent to more than thirty percent (using my anecdotal figures).
So there you go, explain that one.
Saturday, February 11, 2012
Irish government living on cloud cuckoo.
Irish prime minister (Taoiseach) and environment minister both showing how out of touch with the reality of living in Ireland in 2012. Enda Kenny thinks a pint of beer is over five euro, and that its normal to pay over a fiver for a pint, and Phil Hogam thinks one hundred euro is a trivial sum of money.
Listen to it here.
Monday, January 30, 2012
Government deference to the Attorney General.
A few short months ago the current minister for justice Alan Shatter basically said that 8 former attorneys general did not know what they were talking about, and also he implied that some of them might even have a hidden agenda in relation to the referendum on parliamentary committees. http://www.rte.ie/news/2011/1024/referendum.html
In reality he dismissed the former office holders as not knowing what they were talking about, which is quite unusual as the office of attorney general and it's holders are usually referred to (in political terms at least) almost as godlike, and very definitely absolutely beyond any form of reproach, both for competence and integrity.
This is a huge departure from the political norm, and I take it that Alan Shatters opinions (as minister for justice) is far more significant and knowledgeable about legal matters, than the paid staff I.e. the attorney general. I mean why would you need a minster for justice if you are going to reverentially defer to the attorney general every time a legal issue arises. There is a political deference to the office of attorney general, in that the office is supposed to be the highest source of independent legal advice available to the government, and maybe that's true, I,ve never been at a cabinet meeting, so I can,t say for definite, but suffice this for definite, the office is treated as royalty, and constantly referred to in political terms, both by the government and opposition parliamentarians.
I was quite shocked to read Alan Shatter' comments as they seemed to dismiss the former office holders as not being legally competent, and also some had a less than perfect level of integrity, in, that they were using their hidden personal agendas, to stop what the government seen as a forward thinking means to grant themselves more power to investigate people. Anyway the referendum was not passed by the people, so to a certain extent and from a certain perspective you could say that the government got it wrong and the former attorneys general got it right. So in that case you would have decide yourself who is most competent, the minister or the attorneys general?
Either way I assumed the minister and the government had decided the ministers office was the most important of the two offices, considering the ministers office is capable of passing laws affecting citizens, while the attorney generals office is only as a paid legal advisor, or indeed the governments solicitor.
All that being said I,m a bit shocked the hear the government ministers again referring to the attorney generals office in reverential terms when it comes to the possibility of whether the Irish citizens will get a referendum on the fiscal compact treaty being negotiated in this decade of austerity. It appears the government have got over their hang ups they had against the other former office holders, when it comes to the possibility of a referendum, so the office of attorney general in Ireland is now back as being acknowledged (by the government) as the most competent legal advisor in the land. The line is, "if the wording of the treaty needs a referendum, then the attorney general will tell us that, and then we will have a referendum", so that's it then, the big government knows best.
Somehow I have a feeling that it will not stop there. In reality which is my world, somebody will challenge the governments refusal to hold a referendum, one way or the other, someone will push this all the way to the supreme court.
And then, we will see who, is really, the most competent legal advisor in the land.
In reality he dismissed the former office holders as not knowing what they were talking about, which is quite unusual as the office of attorney general and it's holders are usually referred to (in political terms at least) almost as godlike, and very definitely absolutely beyond any form of reproach, both for competence and integrity.
This is a huge departure from the political norm, and I take it that Alan Shatters opinions (as minister for justice) is far more significant and knowledgeable about legal matters, than the paid staff I.e. the attorney general. I mean why would you need a minster for justice if you are going to reverentially defer to the attorney general every time a legal issue arises. There is a political deference to the office of attorney general, in that the office is supposed to be the highest source of independent legal advice available to the government, and maybe that's true, I,ve never been at a cabinet meeting, so I can,t say for definite, but suffice this for definite, the office is treated as royalty, and constantly referred to in political terms, both by the government and opposition parliamentarians.
I was quite shocked to read Alan Shatter' comments as they seemed to dismiss the former office holders as not being legally competent, and also some had a less than perfect level of integrity, in, that they were using their hidden personal agendas, to stop what the government seen as a forward thinking means to grant themselves more power to investigate people. Anyway the referendum was not passed by the people, so to a certain extent and from a certain perspective you could say that the government got it wrong and the former attorneys general got it right. So in that case you would have decide yourself who is most competent, the minister or the attorneys general?
Either way I assumed the minister and the government had decided the ministers office was the most important of the two offices, considering the ministers office is capable of passing laws affecting citizens, while the attorney generals office is only as a paid legal advisor, or indeed the governments solicitor.
All that being said I,m a bit shocked the hear the government ministers again referring to the attorney generals office in reverential terms when it comes to the possibility of whether the Irish citizens will get a referendum on the fiscal compact treaty being negotiated in this decade of austerity. It appears the government have got over their hang ups they had against the other former office holders, when it comes to the possibility of a referendum, so the office of attorney general in Ireland is now back as being acknowledged (by the government) as the most competent legal advisor in the land. The line is, "if the wording of the treaty needs a referendum, then the attorney general will tell us that, and then we will have a referendum", so that's it then, the big government knows best.
Somehow I have a feeling that it will not stop there. In reality which is my world, somebody will challenge the governments refusal to hold a referendum, one way or the other, someone will push this all the way to the supreme court.
And then, we will see who, is really, the most competent legal advisor in the land.
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Impossible recycling
Below is a press release by fianna fail td Charlie OConnor. The reality of this statement is that every worker will have to manually handle one and a half tonnes per day to reach MrOConnors figures.
Slavery is back.
New materials recovery facility for Dublin Region to create over 180 jobs - O'Connor
Environment Department to invest a further €13 million over 5 years
Statement by Charlie O'Connor at 14:15 Yesterday
Dublin South West Fianna Fáil TD, Charlie O'Connor attended the opening of a major new materials recovery facility to serve the Dublin region.
Deputy O'Connor said: "The state-of-the-art facility, located at Ballymount in Dublin 12, will process all the Green Bin materials in the Dublin region for the next 20 years. It is a joint operation between the four Dublin local authorities."
"During discussions with Minister Gormley, he outlined that this facility will employ over 180 jobs; 85 people on site with a further 100 collecting green bins. I understand that it will have a capacity of 100,000 tonnes per annum."
"It is vital that this government continues to invest in green infrastructure to ensure sustainable economic development, secure future job creation and to provide people with the highest standards in green services.
"The facility has received over €26 million and I am delighted that the Department of the Environment is committed to investing a further €13 million over the next 5 years."
"Those who wish to seek further information on recycling services in the Dublin area can log onto www.DublinWaste.ie," said Deputy O'Connor.
ENDS
http://www.fiannafail.ie/article.phpx?id=10048&nav=RSS
Slavery is back.
New materials recovery facility for Dublin Region to create over 180 jobs - O'Connor
Environment Department to invest a further €13 million over 5 years
Statement by Charlie O'Connor at 14:15 Yesterday
Dublin South West Fianna Fáil TD, Charlie O'Connor attended the opening of a major new materials recovery facility to serve the Dublin region.
Deputy O'Connor said: "The state-of-the-art facility, located at Ballymount in Dublin 12, will process all the Green Bin materials in the Dublin region for the next 20 years. It is a joint operation between the four Dublin local authorities."
"During discussions with Minister Gormley, he outlined that this facility will employ over 180 jobs; 85 people on site with a further 100 collecting green bins. I understand that it will have a capacity of 100,000 tonnes per annum."
"It is vital that this government continues to invest in green infrastructure to ensure sustainable economic development, secure future job creation and to provide people with the highest standards in green services.
"The facility has received over €26 million and I am delighted that the Department of the Environment is committed to investing a further €13 million over the next 5 years."
"Those who wish to seek further information on recycling services in the Dublin area can log onto www.DublinWaste.ie," said Deputy O'Connor.
ENDS
http://www.fiannafail.ie/article.phpx?id=10048&nav=RSS
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
Surviving the Recession
I have a novel way to get us through the recession.
Instead of the Irish government asking the little people of Ireland to accept a reduction in their standard of living (in real terms) and in their patriotic duty of course and in the national interest, they should ask the bosses to accept an increase in their income tax for a period of (lets say two years)also no wage increases and no price increases, and ordinary workers would do the same (but without the tax increases).
The government can also force the energy suppliers i.e. Gas Electricity, Petrol, Diesel to not increase their prices and any international cost increases should be absorbed by these companies also for the same two years and in their patriotic duty of course and in the national interest.
This would result in all companies maintaining a status quo, with no increases in salaries for anybody, and would also mean living standards stay the same for everybody until the international economy recovers, it will give time for the housing issue to calm down and ultimately give time to devise a new strategy that will return competiveness to Irish companies. It will also mean the Government can devise policies to address the difference in the cost of living in other EU countries.
The cost of living in other less expensive property countries is the prime issue affecting competitiveness of companies that are relocating to other parts of the world. Within the EU we require every citizen to enjoy a certain standard of living and as such when a small country like Ireland is competing against larger EU countries, we have no chance, unless we can use other means to sell goods and services i.e. Ireland needs to become a knowledge society, however it’s most likely that it will take thirty years to achieve that, but with the governments cutbacks in education it’s an impossible reality this side of the twenty second century.
As an aside but probably the inspiration for this piece was a discussion I had with a lovely person, a senior executive with Diageo, a company with profits of about 2 billion per year. (I’m trying not to generalise about this person as I do not want to identify the person, as I did not ask them if I could quote them, maybe their colleagues know this person because of their views, but I can’t do anything about that) anyway this person told me, they flew their child to America for health services because they were afraid to subject the child to Irish medical standards. On it’s own that speaks volumes, however this person also told me that big international companies would not locate in Ireland because the standard of living / infrastructure such as health services etc, would not allow these companies to locate in Ireland because these companies can not attract the people with the skills the companies need, even the low rate of corporation tax does not help these companies, as there culture is also about the right people to do the job, otherwise there is no point in being anywhere, if logically you can’t get the right people to do the job in that locality and those that they trust will not relocate, then despite the low corporation tax rates means these companies can not do the job in the low tax country, then ultimately they go where they can do the job and get the money. It’s a quite simple logic really.
The real problem for Ireland has been the Irish government’s belief that every American company would want to locate in Ireland, because of the low corporation tax rate. Reality shows these companies that came to Ireland in the 1990s have experienced bad working experiences by their staff who are now advising their friends and colleagues that the standard of living in my Country is way below what they can expect.
Ireland in theory is a great classless society, because in reality even if you have money which can afford you the very best of every public service available, in my mind and in the mind of the Diageo person, the standards in my country are akin to a developing country rather than a country that carries its citizens to the highest standards in the world.
My own opinion is that most people would be horrified to know the same party has been in government in Ireland for 75 of the last 85 years and the standards here are still developing. My reality is that standards in Health services (both public and private) are still way behind the rest of the real world.
I’m sorry to say that but it’s my perception which is my reality, but this was also reaffirmed by the Diageo executive.
Instead of the Irish government asking the little people of Ireland to accept a reduction in their standard of living (in real terms) and in their patriotic duty of course and in the national interest, they should ask the bosses to accept an increase in their income tax for a period of (lets say two years)also no wage increases and no price increases, and ordinary workers would do the same (but without the tax increases).
The government can also force the energy suppliers i.e. Gas Electricity, Petrol, Diesel to not increase their prices and any international cost increases should be absorbed by these companies also for the same two years and in their patriotic duty of course and in the national interest.
This would result in all companies maintaining a status quo, with no increases in salaries for anybody, and would also mean living standards stay the same for everybody until the international economy recovers, it will give time for the housing issue to calm down and ultimately give time to devise a new strategy that will return competiveness to Irish companies. It will also mean the Government can devise policies to address the difference in the cost of living in other EU countries.
The cost of living in other less expensive property countries is the prime issue affecting competitiveness of companies that are relocating to other parts of the world. Within the EU we require every citizen to enjoy a certain standard of living and as such when a small country like Ireland is competing against larger EU countries, we have no chance, unless we can use other means to sell goods and services i.e. Ireland needs to become a knowledge society, however it’s most likely that it will take thirty years to achieve that, but with the governments cutbacks in education it’s an impossible reality this side of the twenty second century.
As an aside but probably the inspiration for this piece was a discussion I had with a lovely person, a senior executive with Diageo, a company with profits of about 2 billion per year. (I’m trying not to generalise about this person as I do not want to identify the person, as I did not ask them if I could quote them, maybe their colleagues know this person because of their views, but I can’t do anything about that) anyway this person told me, they flew their child to America for health services because they were afraid to subject the child to Irish medical standards. On it’s own that speaks volumes, however this person also told me that big international companies would not locate in Ireland because the standard of living / infrastructure such as health services etc, would not allow these companies to locate in Ireland because these companies can not attract the people with the skills the companies need, even the low rate of corporation tax does not help these companies, as there culture is also about the right people to do the job, otherwise there is no point in being anywhere, if logically you can’t get the right people to do the job in that locality and those that they trust will not relocate, then despite the low corporation tax rates means these companies can not do the job in the low tax country, then ultimately they go where they can do the job and get the money. It’s a quite simple logic really.
The real problem for Ireland has been the Irish government’s belief that every American company would want to locate in Ireland, because of the low corporation tax rate. Reality shows these companies that came to Ireland in the 1990s have experienced bad working experiences by their staff who are now advising their friends and colleagues that the standard of living in my Country is way below what they can expect.
Ireland in theory is a great classless society, because in reality even if you have money which can afford you the very best of every public service available, in my mind and in the mind of the Diageo person, the standards in my country are akin to a developing country rather than a country that carries its citizens to the highest standards in the world.
My own opinion is that most people would be horrified to know the same party has been in government in Ireland for 75 of the last 85 years and the standards here are still developing. My reality is that standards in Health services (both public and private) are still way behind the rest of the real world.
I’m sorry to say that but it’s my perception which is my reality, but this was also reaffirmed by the Diageo executive.
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Friday, June 13, 2008
Lisbon Treaty is now dead, well, maybe it is dead, but then again????
My letter to the people of Europe.
To those of you that wanted a no vote in the Lisbon treaty, there you have it. Some of the people of Ireland has obliged you, so now you can do whatever it takes in your countries to enable the European Union become a more efficient organisation.
To those of you that wanted a Yes vote, not enough Irish people seen fit to vote Yes, so now you also can do whatever is now required to enable the European Union become a more efficient organisation.
I want to explain what I believe happened in the campaign. The No campaign was off the blocks and running at full speed from January 2008. The Yes campaign really only started in May 2008 and it never really got any momentum going at a time when the No campaign was ploughing ahead like a juggernaut running at full speed.
The whole political establishment, and the major media organisations, the trade union establishment (with some exceptions), the business establishment, were involved in the Yes campaign and considering all the resources that were available to it, they ran a dismal campaign in that they expected the Irish people to blindly follow their lead. The fact is that Ireland has been fighting establishments for over eight hundred years and if anybody thought that we would just blindly follow the current establishment, they were foolishly mistaken.
In real terms this vote has shown the difference in class terms that apply in Ireland. It is clearly the most straightforward class divisions that have ever been seen in any vote in the Republic of Ireland. Blue collar workers and lower middle class urban dwellers voted in unprecedented numbers for a clear No. The main reason for this is that, mostly they did not understand the real issues being raised by the referendum. The other reason is that they do not feel that they have ever gained anything from membership of the European Union. Despite many avenues of funding from the European Union (the structural funds et al), Irish governments have spent this money but most people believe that they did not get anything from these funds. Considering that this class of people can not access any state housing, any decent health care services for the sick, children being educated in prefabricated portacabins, (some of which are more than twenty years old), older people being denied home health care, hospitalisation, etc, and public services that are constantly badly managed and deprived of funding (in the name of the European Union), then you can understand why these people do not feel any better off as Europeans. In fact when we travel abroad and see the hospitals and schools etc that are available in other countries, it is quite understandable that many Irish people feel that they are second class citizens of the European.
This is clearly not the fault of the European Union institutions. It is the fault of Irish governments. It is customary for Irish governments to take credit for things that go well, but when it goes bad the European Union gets the blame. An example of this is: Recently the government insisted that schools would have to pay for drinking water. These funds would have to be paid by the parents of the children attending the schools, as the government could not fund these costs because of a ruling from Europe. They clearly blamed the European Union for this decision. It was promptly rejected by the Institutions of the Union and a senior official was despatched to explain to Ireland that it was a decision purely for the Irish government. When people only hear bad news and regulations that they perceive to be detrimental to their well being then it’s very understandable that Irish people will vote against that. Personally I believe all European nations would vote in the same way if their perception of the institutions was totally negative.
All day RTE, the Public service media is inundated with various government ministers and spokespersons berating the Irish people for voting NO, in fact one of the senior ministers made a veiled threat by stating that those who voted No would have to accept the bad consequences and the bad outcomes from Europe. This coded language for what is already a disastrous economy, the highest numbers of unemployed people since records began, many industries finding it very uncompetitive, to exist as businesses on an island on the periphery of Europe. These people could do well to listen to the people speaking from Europe on this issue. They have adopted a very diplomatic tone that clearly shows respect for peoples opinions, and while expressing their disappointment, they clearly want to hear why the Irish people voted No. The Irish politicians seem to want to kick the guts out of the Irish people for not toeing their line.
Ireland has gone from what was one of the richest countries per head of population in Europe, to an almost basket case economy in terms of our inability to compete with the rest of Europe. The reality of this uncompetitiveness is clearly at the feet of the political and ruling classes, most of which have been in positions of power for all of my adult life. The very senior politicians have been in power for most of the last thirty years and the have to accept all of the responsibility for making our economy a basket case. The real cause of this is the price of property in the Urban areas of Ireland. Home prices have increased in some places by 1000% in the last twelve years. However salaries have not increased anything like that and considering other European countries can manage their housing demands in such a way as to improve their economies as supply satisfies demands, instead of the way we have restricted the supply of homes so as to increase prices and ultimately act as a burden on companies’ ability to compete. However when the real consequences of a badly managed economy are being felt through unemployment etc, then the government will blame the No vote for this.
Before yesterday we were cajoled and threatened with isolation from the rest of Europe, we were told there would be no treaty without us, now they are telling us that the other twenty six countries may move on without us, what are we supposed to believe? We are being told that we now have stopped the progression of other countries on the periphery of membership of the European Union; they did not tell us that on Wednesday. I am amazed but not surprised that the Yes campaign is clearly heading for cover and is now blaming those that voted No, and are clearly not accepting any responsibility for their part in the referendum.
I feel the European Union needs to send Independent assessors to Ireland to find out why we voted No in this referendum. They might also investigate where all the structural funds have been spent. We have not built any kind of public infrastructures with the exception of roads, we have not got any more hospitals, school’s, elderly housing, community facilities, social housing, with these funds, so the question remains what happened to the money. An example of a road built with structural funds is the road called the M50. This is a ring road motorway around Dublin that crosses over the River Liffey. The road on both sides of the river was built by the government (or at least that’s how they put it) the fact is that substantial EU funds along with Irish taxpayer’s money were used to build this road. The bridge that crosses the River Liffey was built by a private company that was given a government licence to operate and build this bridge and to impose a toll for crossing the bridge. The government has never satisfactorily answered why the bridge was not built using public funds that would do away with the need to toll this bridge. This is not a grump about paying the toll. The toll booths create a bottleneck that has been known to hold people up for up to one hour. This is a ridiculous waste of time for people travelling to and from work in private cars because of the lack of a decent public transport system. The government is now buying out this company for over half a billion Euro, (as far as the reported figures go) and they are allowing another private company install electronic tolling systems at every entrance to the motorway. The cost of using it is going up and it appears that now you can not use any of this road without paying for it. As it stands the only part of it you have to pay for at present is the use of the bridge. In other words if do not need to cross the bridge you can use the M50 road for free. This is a scandalous situation that is clearly putting the needs of a private company above the needs of the people. Again the Irish government have said that this is because of European regulations that we have to do it this way. If that’s the case we are probably better off outside of Europe.
I must point out that the current political classes will say that it was not them that caused this situation, however the reality is that Ireland has had the same party in Government for almost all of my adult life, with the exception of a brief period when we had what was called the Rainbow coalition which is widely acknowledged as being one of the best governments the Republic of Ireland ever had.
I know this is only one person’s opinion, but in my estimation I have been an expert on normal Irish people for years (see my Blog predicting the outcome of the referendum earlier in the Blog). I have supported the European Union in all of its requirements over the last thirty years and I will do so in the future. The reality is that I and many like me have looked to Europe as our defenders against bad Irish governments and we have not had that defence. For all the good rules and good regulations applied from Europe most of them have been resisted by the Irish government. One simple example is the government refused to give the largest trade union in Ireland a guarantee that the rights of workers to collective bargaining would be ratified by the Irish government, even though this is an item in the Lisbon treaty.
So that’s it in a nutshell, if the Irish government will not give a guarantee that they will ratify what is in the treaty, then, why would we vote for the treaty as a whole.
The one thing I want get across to the people of Europe is this. Irish people voting No for this treaty, was not, in any way meant to be an insult to the people of Europe, or to the Institutions of the European Union. In my humble opinion it is most likely a call for help to free us from the bad management of our country, which has been in the same hands for many years.
I am going to try to send this to every European Union member ambassadors to Ireland to ask them to forgive us poor Irish idiots for not giving the political elites their own way.
If I get any response to this I will let you know.
Regards
John Fitzpatrick
To those of you that wanted a no vote in the Lisbon treaty, there you have it. Some of the people of Ireland has obliged you, so now you can do whatever it takes in your countries to enable the European Union become a more efficient organisation.
To those of you that wanted a Yes vote, not enough Irish people seen fit to vote Yes, so now you also can do whatever is now required to enable the European Union become a more efficient organisation.
I want to explain what I believe happened in the campaign. The No campaign was off the blocks and running at full speed from January 2008. The Yes campaign really only started in May 2008 and it never really got any momentum going at a time when the No campaign was ploughing ahead like a juggernaut running at full speed.
The whole political establishment, and the major media organisations, the trade union establishment (with some exceptions), the business establishment, were involved in the Yes campaign and considering all the resources that were available to it, they ran a dismal campaign in that they expected the Irish people to blindly follow their lead. The fact is that Ireland has been fighting establishments for over eight hundred years and if anybody thought that we would just blindly follow the current establishment, they were foolishly mistaken.
In real terms this vote has shown the difference in class terms that apply in Ireland. It is clearly the most straightforward class divisions that have ever been seen in any vote in the Republic of Ireland. Blue collar workers and lower middle class urban dwellers voted in unprecedented numbers for a clear No. The main reason for this is that, mostly they did not understand the real issues being raised by the referendum. The other reason is that they do not feel that they have ever gained anything from membership of the European Union. Despite many avenues of funding from the European Union (the structural funds et al), Irish governments have spent this money but most people believe that they did not get anything from these funds. Considering that this class of people can not access any state housing, any decent health care services for the sick, children being educated in prefabricated portacabins, (some of which are more than twenty years old), older people being denied home health care, hospitalisation, etc, and public services that are constantly badly managed and deprived of funding (in the name of the European Union), then you can understand why these people do not feel any better off as Europeans. In fact when we travel abroad and see the hospitals and schools etc that are available in other countries, it is quite understandable that many Irish people feel that they are second class citizens of the European.
This is clearly not the fault of the European Union institutions. It is the fault of Irish governments. It is customary for Irish governments to take credit for things that go well, but when it goes bad the European Union gets the blame. An example of this is: Recently the government insisted that schools would have to pay for drinking water. These funds would have to be paid by the parents of the children attending the schools, as the government could not fund these costs because of a ruling from Europe. They clearly blamed the European Union for this decision. It was promptly rejected by the Institutions of the Union and a senior official was despatched to explain to Ireland that it was a decision purely for the Irish government. When people only hear bad news and regulations that they perceive to be detrimental to their well being then it’s very understandable that Irish people will vote against that. Personally I believe all European nations would vote in the same way if their perception of the institutions was totally negative.
All day RTE, the Public service media is inundated with various government ministers and spokespersons berating the Irish people for voting NO, in fact one of the senior ministers made a veiled threat by stating that those who voted No would have to accept the bad consequences and the bad outcomes from Europe. This coded language for what is already a disastrous economy, the highest numbers of unemployed people since records began, many industries finding it very uncompetitive, to exist as businesses on an island on the periphery of Europe. These people could do well to listen to the people speaking from Europe on this issue. They have adopted a very diplomatic tone that clearly shows respect for peoples opinions, and while expressing their disappointment, they clearly want to hear why the Irish people voted No. The Irish politicians seem to want to kick the guts out of the Irish people for not toeing their line.
Ireland has gone from what was one of the richest countries per head of population in Europe, to an almost basket case economy in terms of our inability to compete with the rest of Europe. The reality of this uncompetitiveness is clearly at the feet of the political and ruling classes, most of which have been in positions of power for all of my adult life. The very senior politicians have been in power for most of the last thirty years and the have to accept all of the responsibility for making our economy a basket case. The real cause of this is the price of property in the Urban areas of Ireland. Home prices have increased in some places by 1000% in the last twelve years. However salaries have not increased anything like that and considering other European countries can manage their housing demands in such a way as to improve their economies as supply satisfies demands, instead of the way we have restricted the supply of homes so as to increase prices and ultimately act as a burden on companies’ ability to compete. However when the real consequences of a badly managed economy are being felt through unemployment etc, then the government will blame the No vote for this.
Before yesterday we were cajoled and threatened with isolation from the rest of Europe, we were told there would be no treaty without us, now they are telling us that the other twenty six countries may move on without us, what are we supposed to believe? We are being told that we now have stopped the progression of other countries on the periphery of membership of the European Union; they did not tell us that on Wednesday. I am amazed but not surprised that the Yes campaign is clearly heading for cover and is now blaming those that voted No, and are clearly not accepting any responsibility for their part in the referendum.
I feel the European Union needs to send Independent assessors to Ireland to find out why we voted No in this referendum. They might also investigate where all the structural funds have been spent. We have not built any kind of public infrastructures with the exception of roads, we have not got any more hospitals, school’s, elderly housing, community facilities, social housing, with these funds, so the question remains what happened to the money. An example of a road built with structural funds is the road called the M50. This is a ring road motorway around Dublin that crosses over the River Liffey. The road on both sides of the river was built by the government (or at least that’s how they put it) the fact is that substantial EU funds along with Irish taxpayer’s money were used to build this road. The bridge that crosses the River Liffey was built by a private company that was given a government licence to operate and build this bridge and to impose a toll for crossing the bridge. The government has never satisfactorily answered why the bridge was not built using public funds that would do away with the need to toll this bridge. This is not a grump about paying the toll. The toll booths create a bottleneck that has been known to hold people up for up to one hour. This is a ridiculous waste of time for people travelling to and from work in private cars because of the lack of a decent public transport system. The government is now buying out this company for over half a billion Euro, (as far as the reported figures go) and they are allowing another private company install electronic tolling systems at every entrance to the motorway. The cost of using it is going up and it appears that now you can not use any of this road without paying for it. As it stands the only part of it you have to pay for at present is the use of the bridge. In other words if do not need to cross the bridge you can use the M50 road for free. This is a scandalous situation that is clearly putting the needs of a private company above the needs of the people. Again the Irish government have said that this is because of European regulations that we have to do it this way. If that’s the case we are probably better off outside of Europe.
I must point out that the current political classes will say that it was not them that caused this situation, however the reality is that Ireland has had the same party in Government for almost all of my adult life, with the exception of a brief period when we had what was called the Rainbow coalition which is widely acknowledged as being one of the best governments the Republic of Ireland ever had.
I know this is only one person’s opinion, but in my estimation I have been an expert on normal Irish people for years (see my Blog predicting the outcome of the referendum earlier in the Blog). I have supported the European Union in all of its requirements over the last thirty years and I will do so in the future. The reality is that I and many like me have looked to Europe as our defenders against bad Irish governments and we have not had that defence. For all the good rules and good regulations applied from Europe most of them have been resisted by the Irish government. One simple example is the government refused to give the largest trade union in Ireland a guarantee that the rights of workers to collective bargaining would be ratified by the Irish government, even though this is an item in the Lisbon treaty.
So that’s it in a nutshell, if the Irish government will not give a guarantee that they will ratify what is in the treaty, then, why would we vote for the treaty as a whole.
The one thing I want get across to the people of Europe is this. Irish people voting No for this treaty, was not, in any way meant to be an insult to the people of Europe, or to the Institutions of the European Union. In my humble opinion it is most likely a call for help to free us from the bad management of our country, which has been in the same hands for many years.
I am going to try to send this to every European Union member ambassadors to Ireland to ask them to forgive us poor Irish idiots for not giving the political elites their own way.
If I get any response to this I will let you know.
Regards
John Fitzpatrick
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
I despair at the Media in Ireland
Today the 10th June 2008 has been noted as the day that 48,000 people signed on the dole. That’s the highest for any year since these records began according to the media.
• Concern at record rise in Live Register
(19:34) Employers' body IBEC and the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed have expressed concern at the record rise in the Live Register revealed today.
Courtesy of RTEs website.
Fisherman are blockading Cork harbour trying to protect their jobs.
• Fishermen blockade Cork, Waterford ports
(19:36) Fishermen blockading Cork and Waterford's ports have made a number of demands, which they say will end their protest.
Taxi operators are up in arms over the taxi regulators refusal to talk to them about their concerns over their jobs.
• FG wants Lisbon taxi bumper sticker ban
(17:41) Fine Gael wants to ban taxis from displaying bumper stickers that proclaim which way the vehicle's driver intends to vote on Lisbon.
Courtesy of RTEs website.
It’s the last day for the media to discuss the Lisbon Treaty.
Final push for votes ahead of referendum
Courtesy of RTEs website.
And there’s more where that came from.
What I want to say about this is the media in general seems to have pulled out all the stops to give the Yes to the Lisbon Treaty a massive push in light of the published gains for the No camp in the Irish Times poll. Every radio and TV presenter has now exhausted this topic to the point where it’s driving everybody insane. RTE in particular has shown itself to be totally behind the establishment pushing for a Yes vote although,they will say they presented a balanced view, with an equal amount of Yes and No voices. Maybe they did, but they had another choice and it’s this. They could have ignored it and tackled the real current and more immediate unemployment crisis that is facing this country. However it seems they won’t do that for fear of annoying their boss, the minister for communications, the person who grants them their annual licence fee increase.
Anybody that knows me will testify to my absolute despair at the Irish media in particular RTE and those that either want to work there or those who are friends with the organisation.
I got another dose of reality this morning when I heard Ray Darcy on TodayFM interviewing a woman that is taking part in a show that is airing on RTE tonight. This lady was informative and witty, and entertaining so as not take anything away from her, in fact she was great listening. My real problem is this: Why did Ray Darcy and TodayFM not find something other than its rivals show to talk about. Considering the small number of serious topics I’ve outlined above, and the TodayFM organisation could only talk about it’s competitors show. What other sector of industry would be seen promoting the competition? Now there’s a mixed bunch of media types for you.
• Concern at record rise in Live Register
(19:34) Employers' body IBEC and the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed have expressed concern at the record rise in the Live Register revealed today.
Courtesy of RTEs website.
Fisherman are blockading Cork harbour trying to protect their jobs.
• Fishermen blockade Cork, Waterford ports
(19:36) Fishermen blockading Cork and Waterford's ports have made a number of demands, which they say will end their protest.
Taxi operators are up in arms over the taxi regulators refusal to talk to them about their concerns over their jobs.
• FG wants Lisbon taxi bumper sticker ban
(17:41) Fine Gael wants to ban taxis from displaying bumper stickers that proclaim which way the vehicle's driver intends to vote on Lisbon.
Courtesy of RTEs website.
It’s the last day for the media to discuss the Lisbon Treaty.
Final push for votes ahead of referendum
Courtesy of RTEs website.
And there’s more where that came from.
What I want to say about this is the media in general seems to have pulled out all the stops to give the Yes to the Lisbon Treaty a massive push in light of the published gains for the No camp in the Irish Times poll. Every radio and TV presenter has now exhausted this topic to the point where it’s driving everybody insane. RTE in particular has shown itself to be totally behind the establishment pushing for a Yes vote although,they will say they presented a balanced view, with an equal amount of Yes and No voices. Maybe they did, but they had another choice and it’s this. They could have ignored it and tackled the real current and more immediate unemployment crisis that is facing this country. However it seems they won’t do that for fear of annoying their boss, the minister for communications, the person who grants them their annual licence fee increase.
Anybody that knows me will testify to my absolute despair at the Irish media in particular RTE and those that either want to work there or those who are friends with the organisation.
I got another dose of reality this morning when I heard Ray Darcy on TodayFM interviewing a woman that is taking part in a show that is airing on RTE tonight. This lady was informative and witty, and entertaining so as not take anything away from her, in fact she was great listening. My real problem is this: Why did Ray Darcy and TodayFM not find something other than its rivals show to talk about. Considering the small number of serious topics I’ve outlined above, and the TodayFM organisation could only talk about it’s competitors show. What other sector of industry would be seen promoting the competition? Now there’s a mixed bunch of media types for you.
Monday, June 9, 2008
Lisbon Treaty 2008
I’ve been saying this for a good while now so I’m going to commit myself in writing at this stage.
In terms of the Lisbon treaty I’m going to vote yes.
I believe the Yes side has handled the whole thing badly and considering the resources that are available to them I am very annoyed at this. I want to vote No, but I do not want to send a negative message to the people in the rest of Europe, cos that’s the way it’s being presented, (I don’t know if the people of Europe want me to vote yes, so I’m sticking with the positive message), however I believe its going to be defeated, because the main Yes side has not presented their case very well.
Here’s my prediction, If there is a low turnout, between 40 and fifty percent, then it’s a minority Yes win. If there is a high turnout 60 percent or more, then it will be a resounding No.
In terms of the Lisbon treaty I’m going to vote yes.
I believe the Yes side has handled the whole thing badly and considering the resources that are available to them I am very annoyed at this. I want to vote No, but I do not want to send a negative message to the people in the rest of Europe, cos that’s the way it’s being presented, (I don’t know if the people of Europe want me to vote yes, so I’m sticking with the positive message), however I believe its going to be defeated, because the main Yes side has not presented their case very well.
Here’s my prediction, If there is a low turnout, between 40 and fifty percent, then it’s a minority Yes win. If there is a high turnout 60 percent or more, then it will be a resounding No.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
